Dairy & Frozen Food

Milk, Cheese, and More

Ice cream in the frozen dairy case

You’ll find local favorites like Jeni’s, Johnson’s Ice Cream, Whit’s Frozen Custard, Hartzler, and Snowville Creamery in our Dairy and Frozen Food cases.

We’re also proud to offer Central Ohio’s largest selection of Cabot cheese (blocks and shreds), dips, cottage cheese, cream cheese, sour cream, butter, and whipped cream.

  • More Ohio milk: Arps (Defiance), Buckeye Country Creamery (Ashland)
  • Local eggs: Hollistic Acres (Wooster) and Copia Farm (Johnstown)
  • Yogurts, including Siggi’s, Greek Gods, Brown Cow, and Wallaby, plus kefir
  • Fresh European and domestic butter, including Hartzler roll butter
  • Dufour puff pastry
  • Specialty cheeses, including mascarpone and crème fraiche
  • Alexia frozen potatoes
  • Dips and spreads from Cabot and others
  • Fresh pastas
  • My Grandma’s Coffeecake
  • Bulk sliced pepperoni, shredded mozzarella and parmesan cheese
  • Lopus Point Waffles (Columbus)
  • Case discounts on special orders

If we don’t have what you need, we can do a special order!